Impact evaluation of extension programs

These biases affect the interest of the stakeholder. One way to address the problem of clustering is to include all the elements within each selected listing, e. The units used in a purposive sample are sometimes extreme or critical units.

Simple random sample of 20 ping pong balls. Systematic reviews aim to bridge the research-policy divide by assessing the range of existing evidence on a particular topic, and presenting the information in an accessible format.

Some types of clusters include employees of business firms, children in schools, dwellings in city blocks, and residents in counties or states. For a given budget and level of accuracy, the sample size of each stratum is determined on the basis of the cost of collecting the data for the desired level of precision.

If 2 were chosen, the sample would include the 2nd, 12th, 22nd, The ping pong balls are numbered from the upper left corner [1] to the bottom right corner []. Suppose we have 49 each of orange, blue, yellow, and green ping pong balls a total of as represented by the four sections.

There are several types of probability samples, e. If a probability sample is planned, there are several methods for selecting a sample. A census also has the advantage of providing information on each and every individual in the population of the program.

Examples[ edit ] While experimental impact evaluation methodologies have been used to assess nutrition and water and sanitation interventions in developing countries since the s, the first, and best known, application of experimental methods to a large-scale development program is the evaluation of the Conditional Cash Transfer CCT program Progresa now called Oportunidades in Mexico, which examined a range of development outcomes, including schooling, immunization rates and child work.

Impact evaluation

One such sample included the following elements: Note that the cluster sample in this example is composed of several stages. In the above example of farmers, the mean of the farmers who are 65 or older is multiplied by.

Multi-State Activity time must also be tied to a named program i. Stratified random sample of 20 ping pong balls. Quasi-experimental methods include matching, differencing, instrumental variables and the pipeline approach; they are usually carried out by multivariate regression analysis.

Some types of lists include: Recall that the five ping pong balls in each group of the stratified group random sample were the same color. In the third example of a research question shown earlier, the sampling element is the household but the data is obtained from individuals, e.

Nonprobability and Probability Samples Suppose you have decided to use a sample rather than a census. This is the reverse from stratified samples, where each strata is homogeneous. White b [30] advocates more widespread application of a theory-based approach to impact evaluation as a means to improve policy relevance of impact evaluations, outlining six key principles of the theory-based approach: COSA aims to facilitate this by enabling them to accurately calculate the relative costs and benefits of becoming involved in any given sustainability initiative.

The key idea here is to apply a consistent, explicit rationale for including and excluding elements on the list from which the sample is drawn. Thus, it is estimated that RCTs are only applicable to 5 percent of development finance.

Systematic samples, like simple random samples, give each element an equal but not independent chance of being selected. A sample of extreme units, e. Simple Random Sample A simple random sample is one of the easiest and least complex samples to select. On the other hand, if an evaluator wants to survey the farmers in a records keeping program, the advantages of sampling are less clear.

Endogenous program selection occurs where individuals or communities are chosen to participate because they are seen to be more likely to benefit from the intervention. Defining the Population A good problem statement is necessary to identify the population relevant to evaluating program impacts.

Should you use a nonprobability or a probability sample?

Logic Models

If we selected the simple random sample shown in Figure 2, we would have selected 5 orange balls, 5 green balls, 3 blue balls and 7 yellow ping pong balls. Difference-in-differences or double differences, which use data collected at baseline and end-line for intervention and comparison groups, can be used to account for selection bias under the assumption that unobservable factors determining selection are fixed over time time invariant.American Institutes for Research Evaluation of the Regional Extension Center (REC) Program—i American Institutes for Research conducted an evaluation of the Regional Extension Center Program for the Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC).

program are usually the guides from which potential program outcomes are determined. However, many outcomes of Extension programs are serendipitous in nature. We don't always plan on all the outcomes that actually do occur.

Keeping that in mind, the program objectives are still the best places to start in developing a program evaluation plan. Logic Models It does this by inviting the author(s) to articulate their understanding of the current situation, the changes they hope to bring about through their program effort, with and/for whom, the activities planned to contribute toward this change, the resources needed to put into the effort, assumptions they are making, and external factors that.

Similarly, according to the US Environmental Protection Agency impact evaluation is a form of evaluation that assesses the net effect of a program by comparing program outcomes with an estimate of what would have happened in the absence of a program.

Documenting the Public Value of Extension; Faculty Impact Tip Sheets; Public Value Messages for Extension; Public Value Workbook; County Offices; Planning a Program Evaluation; Evaluation Management Plan; Evaluation Inventory; Getting to Indicators; AIMS Help: Reporting & Impact.

Part of the Program Evaluation process is reporting of. program evaluation. It is organized into four program. DonÕt expect to measure impact from a single workshop or behavioral changes from a limited media effort. Extension, program evaluations are conducted largely to improve educational efforts and to address accountability.

In action, these pur.

Download
Impact evaluation of extension programs
Rated 0/5 based on 32 review