What Arendt was able to do masterfully was make these controversial ideas without the hindsight historians have today on this topic.
The reason historical comparison only emerged some 40 years after their height of power is because evidence on the two was previously lopsided. Each of their countries had suffered great losses in World War I and were still trying to recover when they came into power.
German unity meant the gathering together of all Germans in Europe, one people into one empire, ruled by one leader. I aimed from the first to Unfortunately Lenin died before any action was taken and Stalin became leader.
Hitler and Stalin did not only use spoken propaganda, they were masters of using propaganda, so they would use many forms of it. Germany did not have enough farmland to feed her population of enough raw materials to supply her factories.
They both grew up facing similar hardships and shared some similar character traits, they both were from lower middle class backgrounds, they were ambitious, intelligent and resented the social conditions they found themselves in. Throughout, Stalin murdered far more people in the Gulag than Hitler had in a whole.
This proves them to be amoral.
People saw them on posters, photographs, art work, and cinema. It was a possible breeding ground for Socialism and Communism, and therefore opposition to Hitler. This demonstrates to us that Hitler aspired to make Germany strong and feared.
A modernized Russia would also provide the farmers with the machinery, like tractors, they needed if they were going to modernize their farms.
The book is important as it introduces the concept of totalitarianism in a way to link Hitler and Stalin. By the s, the party had evolved into a formidable political force and Hitler was soon appointed chancellor to replace the ineffectual Kurt von Schleicher.
This involved people living in Austria, Czechoslovakia, Danzig, Memel and other isolated pockets. Comparing Hitler and Stalin has always proving to be difficult task for historians as they were born 10 years apart in different countries and from different backgrounds. After the revolution he was given many diminutive duties within the Bolshevik party.
In contrast, there have been cases reported where communist authorities released people from the gulags. Stalin was telling people what they wanted to hear and he used this speech to further his cause. Using this power, they would get people to do anything for them, which proves their amorality.
The Nazi party structure was disorganised and chaotic. Stalin wanted to eliminate all elements of party-state dualism. Although there are clearly many similarities between Hitler and Stalin and their regimes, historians in more recent years have attempted to turn this view on its head by claiming that the comparison argument is misconceived because there are more dissimilarities than similarities.
Most Gulag inmates were not political prisoners, although significant numbers of political prisoners could be found in the camps at any one time. All of their property, possessions and funds were seized and both parties were banned.
There is an abundance of images showing Stalin holding a child or a photograph of Hitler portrayed as a heroic man. He closed all education above the fourth grade in occupied soviet territory Related posts: The term totalitarianism is now widely accepted and used in comparative works of two, bracketed the two under this one category.
The largest camps were spread in extreme climatic and geographical regions, such as, the Artic North, the Siberian East and the Central Asian South. Also it was never her original intent to make a comparative work on Hitler and Stalin, the books main objective was more on the National Socialist Party and how it formed a totalitarian state.
Since their countries were still trying to recover from World War I, they desired to restore the power back in to their countries.
There is nothing terrible, or exceptional, or surprising in the fact that they prefer to be outside the party, that they are cutting themselves off from the party. Stalin felt that if he eliminated his only threat, that it would mean less opposition to his ideas.
However, again there are striking dissimilarities between the two structures.
The use of propaganda was a big contributor to the success of both men. He argued that Nazism should not be regarded as the incomparable evil of the 20th century. Both parties were headed by one man and one party who had absolute control over the nation.
Stalin in contrast would justify his actions by referring to works of Lenin. At least, what he believed to be the right direction. Both would do whatever they thought was necessary to further their cause, with no remorse about what they had done.
In his speeches he was able to captivate the audience and whip everyone into a frenzy-like state.Comparing Dictators Adolf Hitler versus Benito Mussolini versus Joseph Stalin - This essay will compare the three leaders who are famous for their dictatorship and totalitarianism during the 30's decade-Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini and Joseph Stalin.
- Evaluating the Historical Comparisons of Hitler and Stalin “Power corrupts, and.
Lastly, the essay will conclude by connecting the analysis of Hitler's dictatorship to the current debate between historical scholars, therefore the central argument will be proved that Hitler personified more competent and constructive leader compared to Stalin.*.
Stalin: A Compare and Contrast “Americans are taught to see both, Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union as the greatest of evil” (Snyder).
Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin are known to be two of the worst humans of all time, although many believed Hitler was as callus as Stalin at his worst about Russian deaths. A Comparison of Hitler and Stalin Angelica Calvillo HIS Twentieth-Century Europe April 26, Adolf Hitler’s Nazi Germany and Joseph Stalin’s Soviet Union are two controversial regimes.
Hitler and Stalin converge and diverge, the cultural influences that shaped their respective ideologies, and the findings of other historians who have attempted a Weiss 2. Comparing Hitler and Stalin In Their Rise To Power, Free Study Guides and book notes including comprehensive chapter analysis, complete summary analysis, author biography information, character profiles, theme analysis, metaphor analysis, and top ten quotes on classic literature.Download